How Does Nose Twitching Affect a Horse?

One research team concluded that nose twitches, when properly applied, are a viable, humane restraint for short usage situations.

Photo: Courtesy Katelyn Gutwein

Before clipping a horse’s ears or administering an injection, some equestrians reach for the nose twitch without a second thought. Others, however, find this restraint method controversial and believe it’s harmful to the horse.

To better determine how nose twitching influences horses, Ahmed Ali, BVSc, MS, of Michigan State University’s (MSU) Department of Animal Sciences as well as Cairo University’s Animal Management and Behaviour Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, in Egypt, compared horses’ behaviors and heart rate with and without twitch application. Camie Heleski, PhD, animal behavior and welfare instructor at MSU, presented the results on his behalf at the 11th annual International Society of Equitation Science conference, held Aug. 6-9 in Vancouver, British Columbia.

In their study, the team performed an aversive procedure—clipping the hair on the inside of a horse’s ear—in eight Arabian horses that had never had their ears clipped or been twitched. The horses were randomly assigned to be clipped with or without a twitch, followed by the alternate treatment, followed by a second ear clipping while twitched. The team recorded the horses’ behaviors, heart rate, heart rate variability (slight rate changes from beat to beat), and the time it took to clip the ears.

The untwitched horses had the highest heart rates and lowest heart rate variability (both indicators of stress), the most behavioral indications of aversion (e.g., vigorous head movements), and took the longest time to complete the ear clipping procedure, compared to twitched horses, the team said.

The twitched horses actually displayed reduced behavior issues and heart rates, indicating less distress, upon the second exposure to the twitch, even nearing baseline measurements, said Heleski.

“You would assume if the twitch was painful, they’d be averse to it the second time,” she explained. “But heart rate and reactions actually decreased.”

Based on previous study results, twitching probably resembles acupuncture and has an analgesic (pain-relieving) effect, the authors said.

“We believe that nose twitches, when properly applied, should be considered a viable, humane restraint for short usage situations,” they concluded, cautioning that their results are not intended to encourage twitch use in place of proper training.

About the Author

Alexandra Beckstett, The Horse Managing Editor

Alexandra Beckstett, Managing Editor of The Horse and a native of Houston, Texas, is a lifelong horse owner who has shown successfully on the national hunter/jumper circuit and dabbled in hunter breeding. After graduating from Duke University, she joined Blood-Horse Publications as Assistant Editor of its book division, Eclipse Press, before joining The Horse.

Stay on top of the most recent Horse Health news with FREE weekly newsletters from TheHorse.com. Learn More

Free Newsletters

Sign up for the latest in:

From our partners