Using Soil-Cement on Horse and Livestock Farms
Most farmers can identify with myriad problems associated with mud forming around high-traffic areas, including areas around horse and cattle waterers, feed bunks, round bale feeders, walk paths, and gate entrances. Mud is usually a result of animals congregating in and around these areas, but increased traffic can enhance the problem. In many cases, finding solutions to mud problems on farms is not the issue--the issue is determining how to make solutions economical.
Concrete and heavy traffic pads are traditional remedies for reducing mud on horse and livestock farms. A nontraditional option is soil-cement, which is about one-third the cost of concrete. Soil-cement is a highly compacted mixture of soil, Type 1 Portland cement, and water. Soil-cement was originally used as a stabilizing agent for riverbanks, and it has since been used as a subgrade and subbase modifier for roadways, water retention structures, and dam construction.
Agricultural uses of soil-cement in Kentucky have been in smaller areas, such as around automatic waterers and feed bunks, horse paths, and gate entrances. In those areas, soil-cement has been beneficial in stabilizing the soil and preventing mud.
Laboratory tests show completed soil-cement mixture is suitable as a livestock heavy traffic pad solution because it will form a hardened, stiff, durable material.
Horses on a soil-cement pad top dressed with Class I sand.
The amount of cement needed to construct a pad varies, depending on the type of soil with which it is mixed and its intended use. As a base treatment for highways and roads, a 4% cement mixture of soil-cement has been used successfully. However, as a surface treatment (as on most farms), the cement percentage should be increased.
Proper mixing when preparing soil-cement is crucial. Improper mix amounts can lead to inferior soil-cement and can cost extra. Research shows that a mix with 6-15% cement by weight will provide an adequate ratio to construct a proper pad. A more in-depth method for determining mixture content can be found by using the tables below.
To properly use these tables, consult a soil survey book for your county, or use the Web Soil Survey (websoilsurvey.nrcs.usda.gov). Soil survey books are compiled for specific counties and contain soil survey maps and engineering properties tables for those areas. For example, the University of Kentucky has a farm in Woodford County and the soil survey map shows a MiB soil (Maury silt loam on 2-6% slopes) for one area of the farm. The engineering properties table contains the classification of this soil, which is located under the label AASHTO (American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials). This particular MiB soil is an A-4.
|Cement requirements for different soils|
|Typical range of |
(% by weight)
|A-1-a||GW, GP, GM,
SW, SP, SM
|A-1-b||GM, GP, SM, SP||5-8|
|A-2||GM, GC, SM, SC||5-9|
|A-5||ML, MH, CH||8-13|
For the A-4 soil, cement requirement typically ranges between 7-12%. The 7-12% ranges are guidelines for cement use. A 7% mixture might be sufficient for a light-traffic pad, but for our example we expected our pad to receive a high volume of traffic. Therefore, 12% was used.
See the PDF for formulas to calculate the number of bags of cement needed.
For a long-term pad on a general farm, 6-15% cement by dry weight is needed. Adding a small size aggregate to the soil before adding the cement is a good way to strengthen the soil-cement while adding traction. Class I sands, or limestone sand, are a good size that can still be incorporated into the soil.
To make soil-cement effective, some guidelines must be followed. The area planned for improvement, regardless of its history, should be free of all organic matter. All grass, weeds, sticks, stumps, and manure must be scraped off and replaced with fresh soil, if needed). Rocks can be a beneficial additive to soil-cement. It is not required to completely rid the area of rocks, as rocks can add to the strength of the soil-cement. However, rock that is too large can lead to poor compaction. A recommended rock size is found in dense grade aggregate (DGA).
Equipment needed to complete site preparation:
- A garden tiller (self-propelled or tractor power take-off driven)
- A tractor with a loader
- A vibratory rolling compactor
- A water source
Use the tiller to pulverize the soil. More than one pass of the tiller might be required to reach the consistency of a seed bed. Use caution; do not till beyond desired depth. Loose soil makes it easier to add rock, if desired.
Add a smooth layer of rock over the loosened soil on a one-to-one (or slightly less) basis by volume. Use Equation 2 (see PDF) to estimate the amount of rock to be applied. Once rock has been spread, make a couple more passes with the tiller to sufficiently combine the two ingredients.
Once a uniform and solid foundation for the soil-cement has been prepared, spread cement over the soil and rock mixture. The cement must be more evenly spread than the rock. If bags of Portland cement will be used, space the bags evenly before emptying them. Once the cement has been spread, make one or two slow passes of the tiller to mix the materials together to form a desired blend.
Add water to the soil-cement mixture. To ensure uniform water content throughout the soil-cement, water should be added to the mixture while it is being tilled. There are two quick field tests to determine if the correct water content has been reached. One is to pick up a small amount of the mix and form it into a ball in your hand. The resulting ball of mix should hold its shape and not stain your hand, as well as be able to be pulled apart without disintegrating. The second test is to form a small amount of mix into a ball and drop the ball from about 10 inches onto the tilled ground. If the ball of mix can be picked up again, the water content is appropriate.
Compact the soil-cement mixture. To ensure a completed soil-cement layer with the highest strength and durability possible, compact with a vibratory sheeps foot roller. Compact the soil-cement mixture until the surface no longer pumps, ruts, shoves, mars, or otherwise deforms under the weight of the roller. If a smooth surface is desired, a smooth drum roller can be run over the surface after the sheeps foot roller. At this point, the soil-cement is ready to be cured.
Stability and wear of a watering pad area that was treated with soil cement two years prior.
After a typical curing period of two or three days has passed, the soil-cement can be top-dressed with 57s (course aggregate with a 100% passing through 1.5-inch screen), Dense Grade Aggregate (DGA), Class I sand (crusher fines), or it can be left exposed. Top-dressing depends on the operator's judgment.
At this point, the soil-cement should be sufficiently cured to support animal and equipment traffic. If the area is small enough to top-dress without equipment moving onto freshly compacted (uncured) soil cement, feel free to do so. Top-dressing will help keep moisture in the soil-cement during the curing period.--Steve F. Higgins, D. Spencer Guinn, and Donnie Stamper, Biosystems and Agricultural Engineering
POLL: Managing Working Horses