Readers Respond: Challenging Feet

More than 1,000 readers of TheHorse.com responded to a poll asking, "Do you think Big Brown's hoof issues might be a factor in his bid for the Triple Crown?"

results of poll on racehorse Big Brown's feet

Results were as follows: 
  • No: 75.35% (761)
  • Yes: 24.65% (249)

Read about his feet in: Big Brown's Feet Not So Bad, Farriers Say.  

Results of weekly polls from TheHorse.com are published in The Horse Health E-Newsletter. Published every week, this e-newsletter offers news on diseases, veterinary research, health events, and in-depth articles on common equine health conditions and what you can do to recognize, avoid, or treat them. Sign up for our e-newsletters using the form above or on our e-newsletter page.  

Look for a new poll on TheHorse.com every week!


  • hmmmm, lets see. Horse on Winstrol Steroid, built up fake heels and hooves.Why not implant muscles?
  • love of money is root of all evil
  • Greedy people kill horses
  • People always get such a scare with the slightest injury...
  • He's a mediocre horse winning against a very weak crop of 3 year olds.
  • They'll run him. Poor horse.
  • horses weren't meant to wear shoes! glued or nailed.
  • His farriers seem to know what they are doing
  • been there with foot problems and hoof/wall separation; it's in the management
  • We use extreme measures to try to remedy over-use damage caused by people! When will we wake up?
  • Another thoroughbred raced with crappy hooves - what a surprise...
  • I think the farrier has the answer at this time
  • No hoof, no horse.
  • not a factor for racing BUT a factor for breeding!
  • Because excellent farriership and the horses desire to win are just a super combination !!!
  • his chances are better if he is shod natural balance
  • not with the professional hoof care he is receiving.
  • It's just to much pressure on a horse's body to race at such a young age!
  • Change the racing age!
  • Anytime there are any weaknesses in the hoof it could potentially pose a problem.
  • Either racing self-governs or animal rights groups will.
  • Good farriers on hand will be sure he is sound and ready.
  • IF a bare foot horse under is own power (and obvious health) cannot compete without shoes ?????
  • All you guys need to stop hating on Big Brown. Your just jealous that he won.
  • Not if he has sound feet and good shoeing!
  • After Eight Belles I am done with horse racing. It should be banned.
  • Hoof issues ALWAYS affect how a horse moves, but alternatives can help.
  • not at all it is just the same racing shoes just added padding that is the only differnce
  • EVERY athlete has flaws and when there heart is in the game (like big brown's) they learn toovercome
  • I think his shoes are doing their job.
  • The only issue for me is the cruelty of the racing industry, He should be home in a paddock!
  • his problems seem to be older
  • Farriers--great ones--can do wonders!
  • any horses hooves could have an effect on the triple crown
  • After the derby's loss of 8 belles I refuse to watch it anymore!
  • yes i do because i love horses and iv read all the horse things and i really do think it would help
  • win loose or die, the owner gets rich and the horse is abused.
  • I think that level of stress on any horse makes it an issue
  • Hopefully they will pull his shoes when he is done racing and let his hoof's heal. No hoof No horse!
  • He's awesome he'll be lucky to have other competition
  • Horrible feet! Horrible shoes and repairs. I'm a dedicated barefooter
  • I hope he does it, horse racing desparately needs a hero!
  • his foot issues should also give one pause when choosing to breed to him (or not.)
  • He has the best of care
  • Breeding for speed vs. quality; you lose something in the process -- I don't agree with it.
  • They race them too young & train to young
  • Not with those shoes! They are awesome and should be standard for ALL horses!
  • We could see another fatality on the track. Horse racing needs to be abolished.
  • I think that bad hooves shouldn't be bred.
  • He has great farriers, seams like they fixed the problem already.
  • The special shoes seem to be working to prevent the quarter cracks.
  • I believe that his owners will be sure to keep him as sound as possible
  • have won money on him expect more
  • They obviously are not bothering him now and I am sure his Farriers are among the best they can get.
  • No,the trainer will give extra TLC between no and the Belmont,go Big Brown,deliver the big one 4 us.
  • His feet seem A o.K. as he has a very good farriers on this
  • I think people are making a huge ordeal out of nothing.
  • It would appear that his hoof issues have been dealt with successfully.
  • at least I hope not! I want to see him WIN!
  • The fact of steriod use will negate the bad feet. I can't believe this is an accepted practice!!
  • Sounds like his farriers know what they're doing.
  • I'll be rooting for Big Brown!
  • looks like under control for 3 more wks
  • Is it really responsible to make him a major stud with such a defect?
  • it really depends on how his feet hold up between now and then, if no obvious damage than no problem
  • Just read your article and so it sounds like feet are under control.
  • As long as they keep the same type of shoes on him, he should have no problem.
  • as long as the hoof filler stays in place. In the pictures it seems that he has a putty filler.
  • clearly his farriers have this under control. Horses feet issues are usually correctable
  • Not with the special shoes he's getting! He is awesome!
  • I truly believe in corrective shoeing. I have a TB that has made a remarkable change due to this met
  • His farriers obviously have it under control.
  • It sounds to me that they have taken care of the problem so it is no longer an issue.
  • I think if his problems are that severe, why race him? Another accident & death?
  • It is an additional 'something' to worry about.
  • If he had them in the other too races it is going to be the same for him.
  • Maybe, maybe not. We have to wait and see. Bless his heart. I guess we need another Barbaro...
  • new cushioned shoes made fopr this horse
  • Sometimes glued shoes come off and take the hoof too.
  • as a farrier I think his shoes will not have any factors as long as the superfast and adhear hold
  • It would appear that his farrier has solved the problem using the glue on shoes.
  • he should be fine
  • Quarter cracks are common on race horsees and these 2 farriers seem to ahve everything under control
  • Ian McKinlay is doing a good job on his feet and there should be any problem.
  • there are far worse hoof issues besides this
  • Good feet, bad feet - this horse has tremendous speed
  • no, not after reading what they are doing for him with Yasha pads.
  • It sounds like these glue on shoes are effective
  • He no longer has "issues"!
  • They would not take that chance to lose him now.He is as exciting as watching Secretariat
  • After winning the Preakness today, I'd say no.
  • They've been working on them for a while. He has fabulous farriers to keep his feet in great shape.
  • Why take the chance after the recent fatalities.
  • GO BIG BROWN!!!! TRIPLE CROWN HERE HE COMES!!!!
  • It appears that a thorough analysis has been done of the issues and a successful solution determined
  • You can't hurry healing! Hoprfully the worst is over...
  • If he indeed had problems only with abscesses and they're healed his feet should hold up .
  • Pounding of hooves & delicate legs... NO racing until3 yrs old
  • He has a heck of a farrier! Without him B.B whouldn'd have a chance.
  • Unless they are being less than truthful
  • Screw the risk of a catastrophic death like the others, lets race him anyway! People are disgusting
  • Horses w/foot "problems" compete successful in many disciplines w/competent farrier.
  • His feet are well managed
  • Horse racing is evil and should be illegal
  • won't be a factor - he is an awesome athlete
  • Racing a physcially developing youngster leads to foot and other breakdown.
  • He's made it 2/3s of the way, hopefully he can finish that and be on his way to stud. He's so cute!
  • Proper shoeing, which he has will help
  • They have it under control
  • He is being used to make money, he will break down, no hoof no horse. He will die. It is that simple
  • Saw the Yasha shoes...ok..could have better breakover/knee and pastern stress.
  • Great farriers working on him
  • He's done well so far.
  • I knew he was great when I saw h im in the Florida derby. I knew he would win the Triple Crown
  • Compliments to the farriers
  • No hoof, no horse, he'll be find so long as they maintain them...
  • His feet WERE a problem; the glue-on shoes are resolving it. GO GET 'EM, BB!!
  • Seems like the glue on shoes are working, TB's are notorious for bad feet.
  • Sounds like they are on top of it.
  • Long as he wins, what does it matter if his hooves shatter once he's across the finish line?
  • Not with diligent care
  • To save his feet, he may not be properly conditioned to face the 1 1/2 mile race.
  • I think it's abusive to be running these young horses, and they should be barefoot.
  • That last quarter mile in the Belmont is what makes or breaks a Triple Crown winner.
  • "hopefully, great feet"
  • High tech farriery can keep him sound but will he pass on his feet to his offspring?very likely...
  • Sure doesn't look like it's a problem
  • A positive factor. He's lucky to be wearing the plastic shoes instead of the aluminum.
  • Race horses are so competitive they will run without hooves.
  • His farrier is on top of it, he is a strong contender for a historical conclusion!
  • Sounds like his farrier's are keeping him sound
  • glue's just as good nails : )
  • The current method of repair probably makes his feet STRONGER than a normal trim and shoe.
  • It sounds like they have his feet problems under control
  • We like our Equiflex synthetic shoes on our endurance horses .
  • Could be. Everything and then some can be an issue in racing....
  • It is a shame that he will sire many with poor feet like himself.
  • Big Brown is awesome! He will be the next Triple Crown Winner!
  • Could they be from someone nailing in the white line???
  • Wake up! METAL SHOES increase concussion. Go BAREFOOT
  • he won so handily in the Preakness without even being asked -they wont stop a Triple Crown.
  • He should NOT be pushed...we do not need Another Eight Belles incident in racing!!!!!
  • It won't be his feet that make him lose. It'll be the FASTER COMPETITION.
  • Sounds like the ferrier/trainer have the right treatment plan in place. Should not be a problem.

About the Author

Erin Ryder

Erin Ryder is a former news editor of The Horse: Your Guide To Equine Health Care.

Stay on top of the most recent Horse Health news with FREE weekly newsletters from TheHorse.com. Learn More

Free Newsletters

Sign up for the latest in:

From our partners